Make it Transformational: A Blog for Champion Discipleship


The 2010 Challenge

Dec 29, 2009

I recently re-read an article that I wrote back in June of 2008.  As 2010 approaches, the concept still applies and (I believe) presents a challenge for all non-profits.

In connection with writing this article, I interviewed Doug Pillsbury, a consultant who has worked for many years in the ministry and nonprofit sector (and who happens to be my brother-in-law!).  Here are some highlights…

American consumers continue to gather for themselves at an incredible rate.  As a result, Americans cannot contain all they own in their own homes.  In a recent Slate Magazine article entitled “Self-Storage Nation,” Tom Vanderbilt reports “…the storage industry now exceeds the revenues of Hollywood.  One in 11 American households owns self-storage space.” Americans continue to gather for themselves, pay to store their possessions, and rarely or never visit their storage units after filling them.

Recent studies, however, have linked giving (not accumulating) to happiness.  A revealing study in the March 21 issue of Science concluded: “Money can buy happiness, at least when you spend it on others…in a ‘pro-social’ manner.”

Doug Pillsbury (a consultant who has worked for many years in the ministry and nonprofit sector) concurs.  “I have worked closely with many generous people. Whether they give money or things, they are, almost without exception, happier and more grateful than those who choose not to give.  Giving helps a person realize that material wealth is temporal; the money or possessions are not theirs, but God’s.”

While nonprofits welcomed the Science study, Pillsbury asserts that most missed the fact that this truth applies to them as well. “Many nonprofits make the same mistake and view fundraising as an opportunity to accumulate more money for their organizations,” Pillsbury says. “They are eager to take something from donors rather than seizing the opportunity to disciple and give back to donors.”

Pillsbury maintains that if nonprofits could apply this insight to themselves – that giving actually produces happiness – their relationships with donors would change dramatically.

“Jesus warns us in Luke 12 about building storage barns simply to accumulate more ‘stuff,’” says Pillsbury.  According to Pillsbury, too many nonprofits and foundations are doing just that, establishing endowments that in some cases reach billions of dollars, but only giving away a minuscule portion.

Pillsbury concludes: “The fields are white for harvest now. It’s time for the nonprofit and foundation community to put our money to work rather than keeping it in storage.”

The 2010 Challenge:  Be a giving, not a taking-from-others, nonprofit.

2 responses to “The 2010 Challenge”

  1. Steve Marr Says:
    I know one ministry that has a policy of giving 10% of all income to other ministries. They believe tithing should be for them, as well as others.

    I agree we need to save for the future, but when building endowments, we need to ask the question, what are we saving for?
  2. Jonathan Says:
    Great point, Steve. Appreciate that perspective and something to think about, for sure.

Leave a Reply